Labyrinthine beings, re/formulated dreamlike as contemporary creatures in Art
Giannis Markantonakis · Chaniotika Nea, 2019
KIERKEGAARD · PHILOSOPHY · In memory of G. Maniatis
...I asked (a last demand, and a first)
for my brother to hear, as guarantor,
that I not be burned, that they not cremate me;
I asked only that they lay me out whole,
that they mourn my disarmed body whole
and bury it. A monument of a man.
The only prize of my life.
My only way of rising in revolt
against whatever they decreed as fate. And against whoever did.
Alone I decided on the journey
into the most radiant darkness.
What other freedom more longed-for?
From “Ajax” by Pantelis Boukalas (1)
BOUKALAS · DREAMLIKE WRITING
I chose to begin with these lines by P. Boukalas immediately after watching Stavros Psillakis's stunning documentary “For No Reason – encounters with Giorgos Maniatis”. I chose them as a dialectical counterpoint to the tragic, “anti-heroic” death of Maniatis, who lived longing to widen the limits of his freedom on a solitary journey, as a Dionysian rebel of the mind against the labyrinthine corridors of the system, a course he had charted from childhood through self-psychoanalysis and philosophy... I draw out another 8 lines from the same poem by Boukalas: “with calm blood I choose it / that my life is my only possession. / Small? Yet mine. I am its master. / I bring it to an end, / since my name had already been ratified / by the endless aiai of grief / before gods and goddesses decided on the end /”
“We also owe a second birth,” Maniatis declares, emphatically yet simply, holding his fateful pipe, to Stavros Psillakis, who, unseen, films his magnificent views, having foreseen the importance of recording him as if he knew of his end. “We are no more Greek than Heidegger,” says Maniatis of the leading German philosopher of the 20th century, a lover of ancient Greek thought, controversial because of his pro-Nazi involvement (this text is being written late on the 28th of October, as ERT2 is broadcasting two stunning anti-fascist documentaries (2)). I pick up P. Boukalas's small book of poems “The Seer” and copy out: “.. The world a myth. A shadow's untranslatable dream. And the world one kin, one blood, the blood that flows forever seeking its first bed. The cousins, the brothers of Cadmus, his children by Harmonia, his nephews, his grandchildren, Phoenix, Cilix, Thasos, Europa, Minos, Illyrius, Danaus, Aegyptus. And above all Dionysus, for if he, our benefactor, sharpens the mind, and he alone, memory turns back to the ancient, the undivided, and is blessed by the myth...”
PSILLAKIS'S TIME CAPSULE
Chania, 7th Film Festival
The screening schedule of the distinctive documentary and fiction films finds Stavros Psillakis discreetly watching, with interest, from the back rows, the films of mostly younger colleagues. Naturally, Stavros, who, thanks to his merit and his very friendly personality, received hundreds of congratulations after the screening of his film on Maniatis (the Cultural Centre was packed; I don't remember a bigger crowd), stayed on to follow the Festival programme in the days that followed as well.
During the breaks, the welcoming space of the Centre was bursting with life, contacts, banter and jokes in little huddles; it was as if Mathios Frantzeskakis had directed the setting too, though credit also goes to the dozens of devoted volunteers. Maria, Chrysi, Eleanna, Sofia... create a climate of warm human relations, and time changes its rhythm during the breaks... I seize on a silly advertisement in which a well-known actress talks about the “anxiety of animals” (translating the survival instinct into a conscious state) and, as a kind of spontaneous happening, I ask people who are there at random... and I get unconsidered, awkward answers. And of course, that same evening, drawing on the knowledge of the leading “metaphysical” philosopher, Søren Kierkegaard, and his “The Concept of Anxiety” (3), written in Copenhagen in 1844, I contrive the realisation that it is the spirit, and not the psychic world, that, against innocence, defines man's conquest in the face of the time left to him in life; I rephrase: it creates an ARTISTIC experience, that is, ART, which of course still has to be transmuted in practice into a work in which the subject is imprinted in its form as well. The concept of anxiety? I go back to the book and the chapter of the same name, with an excerpt: “...Anxiety is a determination of the dreaming spirit, and in this respect it belongs to Psychology. In wakefulness the difference between ‘I myself’ and ‘my other self’ is established; in sleep the difference is suspended; the dream reveals its non-existence. The reality of the spirit always appears as a form by which its possibility is tempted, but it vanishes as soon as you try to seize it, and so it is nothing but a nothing that knows only how to make us anxious. More than that it cannot do, since it only knows how to show itself. You will almost never see the concept of ‘anxiety’ occupying Psychology; I must therefore point out how utterly different it is from fear and from other similar concepts that refer to something specific, whereas anxiety is the reality of freedom, because it lies within its possibility. That is why you will not find anxiety in an animal, precisely because its nature is not determined as spirit...”
In Psillakis's film, Maniatis, seen up close, is philosophically simple, without tension, without the anxiety of the death lying in wait. Like a Dionysus at peace yet self-destructive, he has no anxiety about his unpublished works. In terms of form, Stavros renders the encounters with a fixed shot, fully aware, of course, that the rhythm rests on the spoken word, which, in its disarming narrative simplicity, is overwhelming; that is why he supports the long running time of 102' with interpolated sound motifs.
The music by Vangelis Fampas is discreetly wonderful. Then there are Maniatis's teaching of ancient Greek dances and, at one point in the soundtrack, the use of the metronome as an accompaniment to the anxiety passed on to the viewer, which by now becomes the very form through which the spoken word is put to use. One more element of formal sharpness, which the director does not inherently possess, he “borrows” and uses masterfully through the involvement of our mutual friend and his contemporary, the acclaimed painter Michalis Manousakis. They work together by incorporating his colour paintings, from which they nevertheless remove the colour, keeping the power of the charcoal rendering, which reinforces the narrative plasticity of the figures against the background of the dynamic intersecting diagonals in his frames; he leaves Michalis's playful scenes in colour, and these bring variety to the form of the documentary, together with the inventive use of the 1970s cassette recorder (4) and the newspaper clippings, or, most overwhelming of all as a document, the focus on Maniatis's burned books as a tragic testament to an existential, surrealist identity. I asked the film critic Rudy Ekstel for a brief opinion on the film, and he spontaneously offered: “A philosophised and philosophical documentary that uses its deeply heretical subject, a man of rare integrity, as its sole tool in a demonstration of precisely what he stands for: we are born not in order to live, but with the possibility of living.”
About Stavros, the contribution of Lefteris Lamprakis and other aspects of the Festival, in a following piece...