Stavros Psillakis
← Reviews & Commentary

FOR NO REASON — encounters with Giorgos Maniatis

Elisavet Chronopoulou, 2019

ELISAVET CHRONOPOULOU (director – writer)

(text she read at the discussion after the screening of the film at the Greek Film Archive, 04-05-2019)

From a cinematic point of view, what I admire in Stavros Psillakis's work is that, using the simplest cinematic tools, and using them in the simplest way, he manages to compose extremely dense yet engaging narratives.

If the technique of storytelling consists in choosing by excluding and illuminating by shading, Psillakis, in this film, starts from a clear choice. He does not organise his material by putting first the question “who is the hero”, a choice that would have led him to sketch a portrait; instead, following a path parallel to that of fictional storytelling, he focuses on the question “what does the hero want, what is his existential need, and what does he do to fulfil it”. In other words, he chooses to tell us an adventure. The adventure of a man who wants to find a place in this world that he is entitled to. A man who, at the age of seventeen, refuses to accept the identity predetermined for him like a label and feels the need to construct an identity for himself, to give that label content, the content he himself desires. And that content is nothing other than the ideal of virtue, as he himself says.

Maniatis is born together with the war and grows up in the smouldering ruins of a world. He comes to know a devastated face of the world, and people exhausted and often defeated by the struggle to preserve their physical and moral integrity. People who submitted to the historical condition, which was none other than the absurdity of war, of the mania for domination over the other, for the annihilation of the other.

He himself says that the mould that made him was the Legion. As I understand it, the mould that made him was precisely the absurdity of the world, perhaps as Camus defines it: man asks and the world remains silent. That silence, at that particular historical moment, must have been deafening, especially for a seventeen-year-old boy. He will not come to terms with this silence. To stand up to the absurd, he decides to break with the world. To become the other: “I want to meet bad people, the worst, and remain honest.” He wants to become the other, the one who will not kill even if he is afraid, the one who will not hate when they spit in his face. That is how high he sets the bar. To transcend his circumstances, he throws himself into their deepest waters.

“And now how will you live?” Nikiforos asks him a few years later.

And he means: how will you live with this identity you have chosen, that of the eternal stranger, of the one who has broken with the world for good?

Of the eternal fugitive?

Maniatis escapes not only from his native land but also from his native condition; he escapes not only from space but also from time. He escapes from the Legion, he escapes from everywhere, as he himself says, and every escape is one more step on his way to constructing the identity he has chosen, that of virtue, which he will one day also define as Greekness. If his identity card describes him as Greek, he sets himself one more goal: to become Greek on his own, to be reborn as a Greek according to what he himself defines as Greekness. If being Greek means understanding Greek meanings, Maniatis renounces the Greekness he was given, escapes from it and, as a stranger, sets out to conquer it, to understand Greek meanings and find there a place he is entitled to.

A place he is entitled to: that is what he seeks all his life.

After all, he always remains the son of the man who pays for a ticket without being obliged to.

“Alcohol has defeated me,” he tells us at the end. Remember me as I was, judge me for what I have been. He looks at us with his clouded gaze and submits himself to our judgement. And when the film ends, we feel an almost triumphant joy, because we know that our hero was not defeated. That the heavy burden he shouldered, the mission he gave himself, to become an ancestor and not a descendant, he fulfilled, since in the end he managed to transcend his circumstances, to transcend the limits of historicity, and to bequeath to us a timeless model of a worthy life.

Looking at the images of his half-burned books at the end of the film, at the notes in the margins of their pages, the line by Sachtouris came to mind: “One day I will wake up and I will have been acquitted.” And I felt great emotion, almost an elevation of the spirit. The adventure ends in success, and the film clearly has a happy ending.

It is the happy adventure of a man who was not frightened by the silence of the world and dared to give his own answer to the absurd. In my opinion, this is the story Stavros told us: the adventure of a vindicated life, of a worthy life.