Stavros Psillakis
← Reviews & Commentary

FOR NO REASON — encounters with Giorgos Maniatis

viewers' comments, 2019

FOR NO REASON — viewers' comments

Viewers' comments, 2019

SOKRATIS KAMBOUROPOULOS (after the 1st screening, 21-04-2019)

The invention of Morel (which keeps the intruders and the beautiful Faustine “alive” in A. Bioy Casares's novel) is simply the film camera.

Stavros Psillakis's documentary about Giorgos Maniatis is not only an important film. It captures for good, in time, the rarely glimpsed figure of Maniatis (who was turned to ashes in his home in January 2018), and at the same time it shares his testimony with us.

Overwhelming people become great subjects (who did not feel a shiver at some point at the immediacy with which all this was spoken and flowed onto the screen on Sunday evening, at the first screening at the Greek Film Archive?). “I Escaped from the Foreign Legion” – a terrible title, I didn't choose it, says Maniatis. “I didn't escape from the Foreign Legion – I escaped from everything.”

A unique case of a man who remained unyielding to the end in the effort to invent himself and to torment the truth on everyone's behalf, giving birth to things that are fully alive, he moves us because he did not count the cost of being, in this way, utterly ignored.

And yet. At the encounter with him on screen, at the Film Archive, there, faithful to the appointment, were his friend Aimilios Kaliakatsos. Lefteris Xanthopoulos. Vasilis Kalamaras. Giorgos Gotis. Miranda Terzopoulou. Ikaros Babasakis and Marili Zarkou. Michalis Manousakis, who illustrated Stavros's film with his works, while Vangelis Fampas dressed it in sound. His students from “Evretirio”.

“You learn a way of playing, you don't learn an instrument,” Maniatis seems to tell one of his students in the video. “The instrument is you; this is just wood.” Elsewhere he recalls a moment from Plutarch, after the defeat of the Persians at the naval battle of Salamis: “Take them yourself,” Themistocles tells a companion, pointing to the spoils on the dead, “for you are not Themistocles” (“σὺ γὰρ οὐκ εἶ Θεμιστοκλῆς”). “That moves me more than anything else in my life.”

Thank you, Stavros. (The film will be screened again on Saturdays 4, 11 and 18 May at 20:00 at the Greek Film Archive, with a discussion after each screening.)

GIORGOS ZEVELAKIS (after the 2nd screening, 04-05-2019)

Giorgos Maniatis (1939-2018), an unseen representative of what he himself called the “belated” generation of the '60s.

I do not hide my joy that his stormy journey has been told by a capable and sensitive director. Stavros Psillakis had a difficult task: he found himself facing an explosive personality who went to hell and back many times, a man of original thought, depth and inspiration. His lens saw him through his successive periods: deserter from the Foreign Legion, journalist, writer, traveller. With understatement, delicacy and precision, he followed the adventurous course of Giorgos Maniatis, who, by many roads, was finally led, in body and mind, to music, finding there a meaning of existence and an identity.

As Giorgos Sarantaris wrote in 1938:

“Wherever we go, music welcomes us; but we are not, we have not yet become dreams, and so we wonder.

We always feel love beside us, following us faithfully on every journey; we know that music does not want love; does it not see it, then?

The fact is that lately our life has become a real feast, with a great deal of noise but also with a certain measure in the merriment it spreads.

Music no longer waits for us only in the street, or when we lean out of the window; it has entered into us, and it feeds us at the most unlikely hours, the hours of sleep.”

TINA PISCHITSI (after the 2nd screening, 04-05-2019)

Stavros, warmest congratulations on the excellent film you made about Giorgos Maniatis! A film that is a model lesson for aspiring filmmakers!

VOULA SARIKAKI (after the 2nd screening, 04-05-2019)

Amazing work, full of poetry, philosophy, music and searching – a masterpiece that we all ought to see and see again, and that should be screened everywhere!!!!! Don't miss it!!!!! Our beloved Stavros, thank you – you are a unique creator!!!! Every success, and may you always be well and go on writing your own story in the world of art...

MARIA BOURI (after the 2nd screening, 04-05-2019)

Dear Mr Stavros, good morning! I was glad to realise yesterday (after seeing the film for the 3rd time!!) how much this work lends itself to many and multiple readings! Mr Kalfas's remark about the “atopon” (the out-of-place strangeness) of our hero was also extremely apt – a characterisation (likewise with multiple meanings!) that has historically been attributed to Socrates!! Giorgos's exuberant personality, of course, tends to steer the discussion towards him rather than towards the film itself, which is where I felt the need to bring it back, and that is why I spoke up despite my (natural and habitual) shyness... Mr Kalfas's other observation, about how the film is received by people to whom Giorgos was (and remains) completely unknown, was also interesting... We shall see!

Once again, thank you!

Maria

SOFIA DELLAPORTA (after the 1st screening, 21-04-2019)

My intervention is not about congratulations; it is my need to state a reality publicly. Having known Giorgos Maniatis as a Teacher and as a neighbour, and having realised that my notebook was evidently counted among the ashes, a reminder of how ephemeral everything is except the sobbing, the tears and the laughter that come from his well-known humour, which the result of your work, Stavros Psillakis, stirred in me, I realise that you are becoming the witness of a new need that the coming age inevitably demands. Your work is not simply one more documentary on the pile of other worthy ones, but a spark and a light for the generations to come, for their search for philosophy and life, and this will become even more necessary as the room to breathe shrinks and young people look for a way out, and the circle will never end....

LILI KANELOPOULOU (after the 2nd screening, 04-05-2019)

Dear friend Stavros, I want to thank you once again for the emotion you gave us today with your excellent new film! The older and more mature you grow, the richer your work becomes! In all the years I have known you, you have kept your ethos and your values intact, and today you spoke to us, in your own personal way, about all the things that are so rare in our time.... Congratulations!!!

KOSTAS DIMOS (after the screening in Thessaloniki, 20-03-2019)

A masterpiece by Stavros Psillakis........ Giorgos Maniatis (1939-2018)..... The calendar read Thursday, 18 January 2018. Firefighters broke down the door of the rooftop flat at 9 Aimiliou Veaki Street and found the charred body of Giorgos Maniatis. An ember from his beloved pipe appears to have set fire to the mattress of his bed and burned down his refuge. Everything in there, after the tragic event, charred.....

ARIS VIOLATZIS (email, 26-04-2019)

Stavros, my dear friend, I have seen the film 4 times, and I cannot put into any kind of structure the thoughts and feelings it stirs in me... What can I say? About the philosophical and psychoanalytic underpinnings of the work? About the relationship between the father, the son, the archbishop, the descendant, the ancestor, about eroticism towards the other as well as towards the same sex, about Maniatis's Oedipus complex, as he desires the mother to the very end while being proud and protective of the father? About the independence of the meanings, the images and the emotions that are conveyed, while at the same time they are experienced not merely as a continuum but as a unified whole that preserves the independence of its parts and combines them in such a way that new properties emerge from them, while the psychic apparatus experiences its mobilisation by primordial, harsh drives freed from the barbarity of the Id, in a uniquely noble way that is the essence of human existence and, ultimately, the foundation of your work and of your personal imprint? I swear that when I started writing this email I was sure I didn't want to write much, because I found it very hard to see how I could possibly choose and capture some of the many intense feelings it has stirred in me. I wanted us to analyse them together, face to face, which will take us many meetings before we can experience it to any real degree. It is not simply your finest work, my friend; it is one of the finest creations in the history of cinema. It stands alongside Casino as its equal in the emotion it stirs in me. I became intoxicated watching it; I kept wondering what was happening to my emotions, until I realised that my emotion did not come from me alone, because it is the combination of my own emotion, Maniatis's and yours. At 1h 11min Maniatis says: “...what burns in us and what we would like to achieve is to become the ancients of the future; we don't want to be descendants, we would rather be ancestors, if possible. These are difficult things, and it will take who knows how many of us and how many decades to achieve anything.” You, Stavros, have achieved this. This film will be used to teach the meaning of art, which, as far as a humble psychologist can grasp it, is to unite human lives by making the deeply personal universal. When you meet the writer and musician who manages to use rhythm and movement, and alcohol too, to console himself and to soothe the effects of psychic trauma, sometimes conscious and sometimes unconscious, as well as the impact of a mood disorder with hypomanic features, in which the mood stabiliser, besides all of the above, is the individual's communication as a person with the little and the big Other, through the very particular narration of your noble intellectual friend (who, besides being just as much an intellectual, is at the same time just as much a rogue as Maniatis, and that is why they got on so well), then you find yourself singing and dancing in your unconscious mind with the sum of these two people, and you can finally understand how Paul could be transformed from an extremely aggressive personality structure into an Equal-to-the-Apostles and a saint.

I have been trying to stop myself writing for a while now, and I will do so now, because I could write so much that you might get bored reading it.

Thank you for your kind words, and although I don't have the abilities to help create such great things, I will accept them with great pride, even if I don't entirely deserve them and deserve them only a little.

Bravo, Stavros, bravo, my friend. Greece, too, has truly high art.

A big hug, and another one, and I hope the film gets what it deserves.

Have a happy Easter, my friend, and I look forward to seeing you soon.

Aris

STAVROS PSILLAKIS (reply to Aris)

My dear Aris, you move me deeply, and I thank you from the bottom of my heart, both for your words and for everything we have shared over the years.

I'm packing my bags for Chania (it's Easter, after all) and I don't have the poetic calm to reply to your writing as it deserves.

I hold on especially to one observation which I think sums everything up: “....who, besides being just as much an intellectual, is at the same time just as much a rogue as Maniatis, and that is why they got on so well; then you find yourself singing and dancing in your unconscious mind with the sum of these two people...”. That must be how it happened, perhaps without my realising it at the time...

A warm hug, and I wish you all a happy Easter and strength. You'll get through it.

Your friend,

Stavros

ELISAVET CHRONOPOULOU (1) 04-05-2019

(text she read at the discussion after the screening of the film)

From a cinematic point of view, what I admire in Stavros Psillakis's work is that, using the simplest cinematic tools, and using them in the simplest way, he manages to compose extremely dense yet engaging narratives.

If the technique of storytelling consists in choosing by excluding and illuminating by shading, Psillakis, in this film, starts from a clear choice. He does not organise his material by putting first the question “who is the hero”, a choice that would have led him to sketch a portrait; instead, following a path parallel to that of fictional storytelling, he focuses on the question “what does the hero want, what is his existential need, and what does he do to fulfil it”. In other words, he chooses to tell us an adventure. The adventure of a man who wants to find a place in this world that he is entitled to. A man who, at the age of seventeen, refuses to accept the identity predetermined for him like a label and feels the need to construct an identity for himself, to give that label content, the content he himself desires. And that content is nothing other than the ideal of virtue, as he himself says.

Maniatis is born together with the war and grows up in the smouldering ruins of a world. He comes to know a devastated face of the world, and people exhausted and often defeated by the struggle to preserve their physical and moral integrity. People who submitted to the historical condition, which was none other than the absurdity of war, of the mania for domination over the other, for the annihilation of the other.

He himself says that the mould that made him was the Legion. As I understand it, the mould that made him was precisely the absurdity of the world, perhaps as Camus defines it: man asks and the world remains silent. That silence, at that particular historical moment, must have been deafening, especially for a seventeen-year-old boy. He will not come to terms with this silence. To stand up to the absurd, he decides to break with the world. To become the other: “I want to meet bad people, the worst, and remain honest.” He wants to become the other, the one who will not kill even if he is afraid, the one who will not hate when they spit in his face. That is how high he sets the bar. To transcend his circumstances, he throws himself into their deepest waters.

“And now how will you live?” Nikiforos asks him a few years later.

And he means: how will you live with this identity you have chosen, that of the eternal stranger, of the one who has broken with the world for good?

Of the eternal fugitive?

Maniatis escapes not only from his native land but also from his native condition; he escapes not only from space but also from time. He escapes from the Legion, he escapes from everywhere, as he himself says, and every escape is one more step on his way to constructing the identity he has chosen, that of virtue, which he will one day also define as Greekness. If his identity card describes him as Greek, he sets himself one more goal: to become Greek on his own, to be reborn as a Greek according to what he himself defines as Greekness. If being Greek means understanding Greek meanings, Maniatis renounces the Greekness he was given, escapes from it and, as a stranger, sets out to conquer it, to understand Greek meanings and find there a place he is entitled to.

A place he is entitled to: that is what he seeks all his life.

After all, he always remains the son of the man who pays for a ticket without being obliged to.

“Alcohol has defeated me,” he tells us at the end. Remember me as I was, judge me for what I have been. He looks at us with his clouded gaze and submits himself to our judgement. And when the film ends, we feel an almost triumphant joy, because we know that our hero was not defeated. That the heavy burden he shouldered, the mission he gave himself, to become an ancestor and not a descendant, he fulfilled, since in the end he managed to transcend his circumstances, to transcend the limits of historicity, and to bequeath to us a timeless model of a worthy life.

Looking at the images of his half-burned books at the end of the film, at the notes in the margins of their pages, the line by Sachtouris came to mind: “One day I will wake up and I will have been acquitted.” And I felt great emotion, almost an elevation of the spirit. The adventure ends in success, and the film clearly has a happy ending.

It is the happy adventure of a man who was not frightened by the silence of the world and dared to give his own answer to the absurd. In my opinion, this is the story Stavros told us: the adventure of a vindicated life, of a worthy life.

STAVROS PSILLAKIS (reply to Elisavet)

My dear Elisavet, I read it again, properly focused this time, and I find it excellent.

The film, like Giorgos himself of course, certainly opens up many subjects and conversations. I feel that the reach of the Work goes beyond me, and that is probably a pleasant thing. The creative fervour at the moment of creation is another kind of magic. You taste it, you follow it, and afterwards you don't know what happened..

And I'm glad I lived this adventure.

Your last words reminded me of an answer I often give after screenings of THERE WAS NO OTHER WAY. I say that these people, however much their visions and ideologies may have collapsed, in the end, I feel, walked upright through their lives. They won their dignity.

As I write to you, a letter came to mind that I had sent to my mother from Paris in 1979 (and recently found tucked away in the family home in Chania). So I write to her:

“.... I left to gain the means to live a life of humanity and dignity, things that money and high social positions don't give you. You only have to look around you and admire them in all their glory. ...”. I had just decided that I wasn't interested in the Polytechnic degree I had, and I was leaving.

Perhaps this will help you understand why I devoted myself so wholeheartedly to Maniatis, to FOR NO REASON, and also why I love THE OTHER ENEMY so much. The question of dignity keeps coming back.

And one last comment on the first paragraph of your text. Yesterday I spent a little time with Zevelakis at the junk shops of Elaionas. Sitting on a log, he told me:

“... I heard Karouzos say at a symposium on modern poetry: if a poem has something precious in it, then it is modern.”

Thank you so much, my dear friend, and here's to what comes next.

Lots of love,

Stavros

ELISAVET CHRONOPOULOU (2) (email, 07-05-2019)

Stavros, you have within you an inner cinematic compass that points you straight to the essence of the subject. That is why you have no need for tricks but speak simply, as simply as can be. That, in the end, must be what talent is.

Thank you so much for the foretaste of the cinematic approach to that adventurous personality that was Maniatis, God rest his soul!