Stavros Psillakis
← Interviews

FOR NO REASON — encounters with Giorgos Maniatis

interview with Dimitris Maniatis · TA NEA, 2020

I got to know you through Giannis Zoumpoulakis. The reason was your documentary about the offbeat Giorgos Maniatis. When and how did the idea for this documentary begin? What was it, basically, that moved you to make “FOR NO REASON — encounters with Giorgos Maniatis”?

Giannis Zoumpoulakis and I share, I like to think, mutual respect and esteem, and I thank him for the introduction. I was introduced to Giorgos Maniatis by the director Giorgos Panousopoulos. They were close friends. Soon I read his book I ESCAPED FROM THE FOREIGN LEGION. I was impressed and immediately looked for information and more of his writings. The help of Aimilios Kaliakatsos (Stigmi publications) was decisive. Reading Maniatis’s texts, I was struck and wanted to get to know him better. A man who writes “Words attract or repel each other, or remain indifferent, just like people. It depends on the quality of the encounter. … A text sparkles with the electricity that words generate in their ‘adventures’ (of an erotic nature). … Whoever does not know how to devise such encounters – that is, to exploit (and indeed to reveal) the eroticism of words – does not know how to write. The one who writes is the one who knows how to make words become unrecognisable.” (MIDAS, Giorgos Maniatis, 1972) is no ordinary man.

After our first 4…5 meetings, I asked his permission to bring a camera along and record our conversations. It would be just the two of us, with no crew. He agreed. All this happened in the summer of 2015.

Let’s introduce Maniatis to the wider public in a few words, if possible. I came to know him through the Foreign Legion. He also danced a wonderful zeibekiko (hasaposerviko) with his brother; I had seen him at various rebetiko clubs...

Unfortunately I never got to see him dance in person. When I met him he was already 76 and worn down…

It is very hard to introduce Maniatis in a few words: an explosive personality, a consciousness in constant alertness, setting itself on fire.

Let him introduce himself: having defined himself as a “public danger”, he goes on: he was born in Messini in 1939. He lived in Athens and abroad. He barely went to school, from which, in any case, he took away nothing. At fifteen he was serving in a petty officers’ school of the Royal Navy. At eighteen he was a coal miner in Belgium, and the same year a legionnaire in Algiers (where he read Proust) … at a time when that country’s war of liberation was going through its most decisive phase. Three and a half years after enlisting he deserted, crossed the desert to Libya and returned to Greece. … He published his first work, under the heading Diary, Algeria 1957–1961, in Dromoi tis Eirinis.

In the years that followed he was a journalist at Eleftheria. In April 1967 he went into self-imposed exile abroad. In June 1972 he went into self-imposed exile in Greece. After the Polytechnic uprising he went underground… (this is what he himself wrote in THE INTER-VIEW, in 1976).

He re-emerged as a prose writer with “Objet sans valeur” (1972), “King Midas Has Donkey’s Ears, or On Either Side of Essence” (1972), “The Mythology of the One or the Mythology of the Other” (1975), “Exerga” (1976) and “THE INTER-VIEW, or So That We Understand Each Other” (1976), which he signed as “an exile from the gods and a vagabond”.

Then Maniatis changed direction. He learned the three-course bouzouki, brought the new rebetiko back to the fore as Greek popular urban music, taught students free of charge at the University Club and founded the “Evretirio” orchestra (1978). He was won over by the “archaeology” of music, and set out his discoveries, his vision and his views in the hermetic and inspired text THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF HEARING.

Through your work you often introduce us to unknown stories, or stories that others may leave in the shadows. What is your basic vision and idea in making documentaries?

I am challenged by people who live through borderline situations: the people in the psychiatric hospital, the partisans who hid for 15 years in the mountains of Crete, the doctors at the Metaxa Hospital who fell ill with cancer themselves... People at their limits who reflect anew on existence. These are timeless stories, but the period and the society into which I was born and in which I have lived shape the way I look at them.

I am interested in the adventures of human existence, and I approach them with a gaze full of wonder, without ideological blinkers or a prosecutorial attitude. I let the people themselves speak and reveal their truth. Of course, with the awareness and deep conviction that all of us “each time, tell the truth we are able to tell”. The mechanisms of deception and self-deception are constantly present, and it isn’t a question of morality but of survival and evolution, both individual and of our species.

During the lockdown – and here is the occasion for us to talk – the N.Y. Times wrote about you. Would you like to tell us what happened? I also saw an excellent note about you by our colleague Giorgos Stamatopoulos...

Because I am a little shy, I will copy out what my dear friend Giorgos Stamatopoulos wrote about the N.Y. Times piece in EfSyn: With great joy and emotion I saw the name of Stavros Psillakis appear among great names of world cinema in a New York Times article entitled “Finding the magic of cinema amid the monotony of quarantine”. The article praised the initiative of the Thessaloniki Festival’s artistic director, Orestis Andreadakis, to commission Greek directors to make a short film about situations unfolding in, or arising from, the enforced confinement at home due to the coronavirus. … famous, award-winning directors from all over the world took part and made small masterpieces. … The report, full of praise for the Greek initiative, presents, with a short summary, the work of five directors: Jia Zhangke, the Argentinian Mateo Bendesky, the American John Carroll Lynch, the American-Israeli Rachel Leah Jones and the Greek Stavros Psillakis, in whose film the maker “converses” with the books that shaped his life and with photographs of people dear to him. …

You have enormous experience in documentary. Has it become harder over the years, or not? I ask in relation to new media, the internet and so on

A reasonable question, and indeed the possibilities offered by new media are often unimaginable compared with the past. But these possibilities are not enough to make a film.

Every film is a small adoption. The subject can be anything: original or not, important or trivial, known or unknown – it matters little. It is not subjects that make films great, but the way we approach them, shed light on them and talk about them. What matters is whether we have something to say, and the aura our creation will ultimately radiate. And here the enormous technical possibilities are not enough. What counts here is the cultivation of the maker.

Some time ago, after a screening, I was asked how long it took me to complete the film they had just seen. I answered: 58 years. That was my age at the time. It wasn’t a cute play on words. It expressed the essence of creating a work, and what you have to summon up each time.

Where did you study, and how did you actually get into directing?

Electrical and mechanical engineering at the National Technical University of Athens (1972–1978). I went to the Polytechnic because I loved mathematics, especially geometry, and also physics and chemistry. In those days good students usually went to the Polytechnic. After I graduated (and engineers were a good catch for marriage back then), I didn’t want to commit my whole life to something I felt had nothing to do with me. And I wasn’t from a well-off family; it was a leap into the void… But as Maniatis says: “Whoever changes their life changes life”.

Directing began much later, in 1985. Philosophy, psychoanalysis, ethnology, poetry, literature (all great loves), and alongside them the loves and the demons that kept devouring me. Those were the instigators. A path full of frustrations, wounds and cracks of pleasure. The final tally will come at the end…

We put it this way, somewhat painlessly and literarily, because in such situations uncertainties and questions never settle, and the truth of any answer belongs to the moment it is spoken – or, as Nikos Kokovlis once wisely told me, “each time, we tell the truth we are able to tell”....

Watching your films, I feel that your centre is Chania, Crete – as if you are forever returning there. Is that so?

In terms of subject matter, that is true only of some of my films. But if we consider how decisive our childhood years are – and I was born and grew up at the harbour of Chania, until I left at 18 to study – perhaps it isn’t wrong to feel that all my films are about Chania. That is where my foundations are, and that is where I stand every time. I can’t hide it, and I am glad you sense it in my films. After all, we always make the same film, trying different things, in the hope that in the end we will get it right…

How do you choose a person to work on? I was struck by the photographer Giorgos Depollas, by his humour and his substance....

He learns the three-course bouzouki and brings the new rebetiko back to the fore as

Watching your films, I would say I completely agree with Stamatopoulos that you make human-centred cinema. Do you agree?

I agree, with some clarifications: creative documentary is a film made on different terms from a fiction film. But the differences between them do not concern the notions of “truth”, “reality” and “fiction”, as we perhaps naively think. Both are fiction. However much we forget it, when you film a person or a situation, you are at the same time filming yourself. That is how your “protagonist” converses with you, and it is you who filters and sees events or situations that way. These observations apply far more strongly to the documentaries we usually call “human-centred”.

If anything common characterises my films, it is that they are essentially reflective essays. The subject, each time, is simply the occasion for an existential quest, with timeless elements where possible.

What was your experience – here is an example of human-centred cinema – at the Metaxa cancer hospital, with doctors who were patients themselves and refused to give in?

There Was No Other Way was, of course, a milestone in your career. Multi-award-winning... How did you learn the story, and how did you reach the survivors?

It all started with a recommendation from my friend Matthaios Frantzeskakis (Director of the Chania Film Festival) to read the book THERE WAS NO OTHER WAY by N. & A. Kokovlis. Suddenly I found myself before the narrative of a Cretan epic with universal and timeless elements. Its “heroes” live through borderline situations, go through shattering experiences and face great moral dilemmas. The challenge for a film was great. But I didn’t want to make a historical film about the Civil War, and it isn’t one.

In Thessaloniki, at the film’s official screening, I was asked why, in the end, its protagonists went through all this. The disillusionments and reversals in the years that followed were many. I don’t know how they themselves feel, I answered, because sometimes they feel vindicated and sometimes not. But I do know that, in my eyes, they walk tall and with dignity. “Now I understand that I am a human being,” says a shepherd in the film.

On the occasion of Short Gypsy Stories as well: do you think there is racism in Greek society, and that the conditions exist for the Roma to be integrated into urban society?

Meaning what? That the Roma should become like us? As if we felt so good about ourselves! It seems laughable to me. Racism is something far more complex and serious that concerns the behaviour and beliefs of all of us. We are not anti-racists just because we declare sympathy for migrants or for other, different, social groups. All of this is tested in practice, and there I don’t think the conclusions are reassuring. It takes a different relationship with yourself to be able to accept the Other as they are, and not as you would like them to be, or to experience them as a threat.

Finally, the Chania Psychiatric Hospital. Two groups of patients: one inside, one outside. Reintegration, a return. Does working on harsh stories and subjects leave an inner imprint on you? Is your camera also an occasion to run through all the contradictions, pathologies and achievements of modern Greek life and of our country (for example, the state of the hospitals, etc.)?